What Would Jesus Do?

I was introduced to a friend’s brother at a party and we hit it off pretty well. We each had a glass of wine and talked for hours. As a swimsuit model, I had been featured in several magazine layouts which I never disclose when I start dating someone — I just say I am a model. Anyway, he asked if he could call me the next day so we could go to dinner and a movie and I agreed. The next day he sent me flowers (he got my address from my friend) and called as he said he would. I was impressed with his consideration, we agreed to go to dinner the following night and he asked if he could pick me up at 8. At the restaurant he ordered wine and asked if he could order my meal for me, as he said he knew what I would like. I said okay, and we went back to having a lovely conversation.

During the meal he asked if he could ask me a “personal” question and when I said yes, he asked if I was a good Christian, which somewhat surprised as he didn’t strike me as religious. I replied that I was a Catholic, but didn’t go to church very often.  He then proceeded to reach into his jacket pocket and pull out a layout that I had done in a bikini bottom and no top, arms across my breasts. He stood up holding the picture and yelled, “Look everyone I’m with a slut! Who wants a piece of her after me?” I was mortified, not about the picture, but his yelling. I stood up slapped him and walked out, but he followed me through the restaurant still yelling, “Wanna see her tits? I’m sure she’ll show them to you.” I was so mad and embarrassed, but then another gentleman stood up  between us, put an arm out to stop my date from following me and allowed me to go.

As I stood outside waiting for a taxi he came out still calling me a slut and a whore. By now a crowd was gathering from both inside and outside the restaurant, with several people trying to push him away from me while he kept waiving the picture and yelling. I got a cab and cried all the way back to my apartment. After being home for about 10 minutes I could hear him outside still ranting, I called the police and while waiting for them to arrive I called my “friend” and told her what happened and let her hear her brother yelling.  The police came, quieted him down and made him leave with no arrest. The following day I received a large bouquet of roses delivered with a card from him saying he was sorry and asking if he could he see me again. Apparently after showing my layout to his friends they told him he was an idiot and was lucky to be going out with a bathing suit model.

He said he reconsidered and if that’s what made me happy he could live with that. I didn’t reply and his sister called to tell me that he called her, not knowing she knew what happened and told her that the date went “very well” and he thought there was chemistry between us. She told him that she spoke to me and I didn’t feel the same chemistry and that he shouldn’t call me again. I never did hear from him again and unfortunately his sister and I don’t talk anymore either, I think she’s a bit embarrassed and I don’t want to risk seeing him with her.

Comments (45)
CallousedJune 29th, 2010 at 7:18 am

Holy crap!!! What a D bag!!! Glad you got your slap in!!

LisaJune 29th, 2010 at 7:30 am

Incredible. Sounds made-up, but I suppose truth is sometimes stranger than fiction.

EmJune 29th, 2010 at 7:56 am

wow, worst dating story I’ve read on here …

lifebeginsat30tyJune 29th, 2010 at 7:57 am

Wow! I want to know what the hell he was thinking! That was just insane. Someone is obviously emotionally unstable. Dodged a bullet there.

BeccaJune 29th, 2010 at 8:05 am

Lisa, I’m with you. This story seems a little fishy. A guy goes crazy on a girl becuase she is a model, but then when he realizes he is lucky to be dating a model he really wants to be with her? Odd to say the least.

AndrewJune 29th, 2010 at 8:16 am

What a creep ass. I was waiting for the “big thing” to be involving alcohol, but I’m surprised by that….jeez.

MargaretJune 29th, 2010 at 8:20 am

How could the sister not know what an a-hole her brother was? You don’t talk to her any more… sounds like no great loss.

Props for a well written story.

hellcatJune 29th, 2010 at 8:34 am

What a freak (if this is real). I’m with Margaret, how could the sister not know that her brother’s a fucking psycho? And how could he possibly think you’d go out with him after that? I guess the really sad part is that there are some girls (girls with shockingly low self esteem) that would.

LisaJune 29th, 2010 at 8:41 am

Becca- Yes, I also find the contrived-set up for the photo reveal a bit implausible– we’re to assume that he had possession of the photo from the beginning of the date, so why the dramatic cat & mouse game?

And, if he’s that fanatical a bible-thumping Christian, why would he simply reverse himself upon the offhand counsel of his friends? My bullshit detector reads code red, frankly.

TheRestOfTheStoryJune 29th, 2010 at 9:40 am

What’s your favorite story in the bible? Did you leave before the bread came? What about the wine?

DuncanJune 29th, 2010 at 10:55 am

Why is it always the people who feel it reasonable to ask you if you’re a good christian etc do it as a preamble to doing something disgusting?* Poor you!

* (Disclaimer – I don’t mean the above to sound anti-religious. I’m not a believer myself but I’ve nothing in principle against those who are. I do have something against morally abhorrent people using religion as an excuse though, naturally).

EJune 29th, 2010 at 10:58 am

I know a few Christians who would not consider themselves Bible-thumpers but rather fairly liberal-minded (usually because of the “heathens” they keep as friends anyway). Even so, I’m sure they would be morally struck dumb if they found out their date happened to be a swimsuit model. For all those out there who say they’re surprised at someone who turned around so quickly after such a reaction, I’m really not surprised at all. Sex to a lot of repressed religious folk is gloriously weird and taboo and people want it anyway and then feel guilty for it and act out. To me, that explains his nutty behaviour well enough. In fact I knew a guy who did a similar sort of nutty thing to me for the exact same reasons, and the only reason it wasn’t more public than he made it out to be was because he’s shy.

If it isn’t fake, I feel terrible for the poor girl, nobody needs to endure that kind of public humiliation.

MeshellJune 29th, 2010 at 11:18 am

I highly doubt it is faked. Homeskillet sounds like he had a bobo for the model and since he was ashamed of said bobo, he decided to shame her publicly. While some details are probably missing, I’m gonna call the “Stop calling BS, Doubting Debby” card since the stupidity of the date (false or not) gave me a good giggle.

JayJune 29th, 2010 at 11:46 am

This is clearly faked..

In the real version, she goes out with him twice more, each time surprised that he hasn’t changed at all. Then he drives her out into the woods, alone…

TMSJune 29th, 2010 at 11:48 am

Well, I’m glad you didn’t stand for him publicly humiliating you like that and gave him a good hard slap. It’s also nice to see that the other patrons were standing up for you, keeping him away from you so you could get the hell out of there. Why he felt flowers and a simple “I’m sorry” would make everything better is beyond me.

ChelseaJune 29th, 2010 at 12:44 pm

I wish this was a funny MVWD… but holy. crap. I am so sorry!

ThandiJune 29th, 2010 at 12:54 pm

He’s a shining example of what a “good Christian” is I suppose. Pity you lost a friend over that, she should have warned you. For his sake I hope he was drunk or high and not normally like that!

unrealted: Andrew sorry I haven’t replied yet, I can’t reply on that site from my phone

ThandiJune 29th, 2010 at 12:56 pm

what is with my spelling! *unrelated

BettyJune 29th, 2010 at 3:38 pm

What a complete ass this guy was. It’s because of asshats like this that I won’t date Christians.

And, this date must be real- who could make this shit up?

gregJune 29th, 2010 at 6:50 pm

I think you should post the bathing suit picture so we can decide if his anger was justified :)

tgJune 29th, 2010 at 7:51 pm

I would say that the guy lacked tact and perhaps was a jerk but the OP was wrong too in using physical force (slapping) against him. However huge a jerk your date may be, slapping someone is illegal and may count as assault and battery unless you are defending yourself from physical aggression.

Of course, yelling outside someone’s house is perhaps also illegal (not totally sure) and I am not defending the guy for his immature behavior.

pook555June 29th, 2010 at 8:27 pm

Wow, how horrible! I feel bad for the OP, but I’m glad she defended herself – bravo! Guy sounds like he probably has some mental issues going on there…

AndrewJune 29th, 2010 at 9:12 pm

@Thandi: It’s all good!

YGJune 29th, 2010 at 10:02 pm

I don’t get why being a bathing suit model is so objectionable. Was she sprawled in the niff on the hood of a car with a candy dildo in her mouth? No? I supposed it depends on the sort of bathing suits in question, but women standing topless with their arms crossed over their fun bags? Please. You see that kind of thing (and more suggestive) in women’s magazines…hell, even some of my knitting magazines have rather racy photos. I’m thinking maybe Mr Bible Freak was threatened by a successful woman and had to assert his dominance. If he wanted to impress by controlling and correcting her obvious “sins”, he went about it all wrong.

I think she should go out with him again and show up wearing a bikini over a Burqa.

SuzanneJune 29th, 2010 at 10:29 pm

Lisa — I happen to agree with you. It all seems just a bit too contrived and made up. I think there’s probably *less* to this story in reality and the OP sort of embellished a bit.

geialgJune 30th, 2010 at 1:03 am

Love YG’s suggestion. What a horrendous experience for the OP. Her date was a total weirdo – like other commenters, I’m glad people stood in to help the OP. I’d like to add: where’s the logic of “this is why I don’t date Christians”? If we used this site as a “shining” example of how men behaved, we’d all be single. ;)

ReesaJune 30th, 2010 at 5:37 am

I can’t believe he’d go to such extremes just to say he didn’t like her job… Nothing else to do that night I suppose.

tronnerJune 30th, 2010 at 9:08 am

I’d love to meet the prosecutor that would charge a woman with assault and battery for slapping her date in the manner described above.

zomboidJune 30th, 2010 at 9:40 am

yes, and give him/her a good slapping

tgJune 30th, 2010 at 4:40 pm

@ tronner: Umm…I am aware of at least two cases where someone was charged with assault and battery for being physically aggressive with their boy/girlfriend (nothing more than slapping and apparently as ‘justifiable’ as the case here). Both cases were published in our institute newspaper. Exchange the roles of the guy and the girl in the above story and see where you stand on the issue. Surprisingly, the legal system is less sexist than what one would have thought (and I am glad for that).

XandrayaJune 30th, 2010 at 5:53 pm

If I were you OP, I wouldn’t bother reading half the comments on here. The same people cry “fake!” over and over again, and even if it is, who really cares?

That’s so horrible! I’m glad you slapped him – sometimes force is the only way to get through to idiots like that. His behavior is completely unacceptable, and you do not have to let him treat you that way. I’m glad the other patrons helped you out! It gives me some hope for humanity…

I can’t believe his sister was shocked. -__-;;

tronnerJune 30th, 2010 at 9:42 pm

You can play up a hypothetical all you want – why don’t you switch the gender, then, instead of a slap, he gently smacks her with a palm frond, but she’s allergic to the palm frond, but he didn’t know that…is that assault? I’m sure there are prosecutors out there that would do it – there are prosecutors that arrest little old ladies for not watering their lawn – it’s within their right, but who really supports that?

The facts (a loose term) here are that the date became argumentative and combative and could arguably be seen as creating an apprehension of physical danger that the OP then responded to within reason. Moreover, she did not repeat the action but left as soon as possible. Out of the two, the person who needs the most help in avoiding future liabilities regarding assault/battery and other personal boundaries is BibleBoy, not our scantily clad heroine.

DuncanJuly 1st, 2010 at 2:57 am

@tg – That something has passed through a court does not mean it should have. Jurisprudence 101. That said, any act of physical aggression can leave one open to charges of assault, context notwithstanding.

MeizJuly 2nd, 2010 at 4:37 am

priceless, ma’m!

buffyJuly 2nd, 2010 at 6:22 pm

@tg- wow, you’re an idiot. The verbal abuse this D-bag was spouting (“Who wants a piece of her after me?”) could be legally considered assault (assault can be verbal, battery is when it gets physical), so if you’re going to play it that way, the slap was in self-defense.

moiJuly 3rd, 2010 at 2:31 am

OMFG what a jerk. he should be lucky to go out with a swimsuit model instead he makes fun of you and humiliates you. This was the worst I’ve ever heard. Hopefully u didn’t give him another chance!!!! Ciao for now

tgJuly 3rd, 2010 at 10:21 am

At least in my mind, verbal assault has much more fuzzy boundaries than physical assault. Most human beings I have known to this date would get much more upset if they are slapped on their face than being verbally humiliated (the latter being much more common, self-consistently).

@tronner: Your comments are appreciated and I agreed in my original comment that the guy may also be charged for assault. But I find your example of palm-frond ridiculous. There is a clear distinction (or rather no comparison) between gently smacking someone with something they might be allergic to (in which case it is not your fault if you were not told about the allergy) and slapping someone on their face. The percentage of people who might find getting slapped in their face offensive exponentially outweighs the percentage corresponding to the people with palm frond allergy (the ratio would be close to infinity).

If someone is unpleasant/obnoxious, then I would think it makes much more sense to just leave the table politely rather than counter-striking physically. Especially if you suspect the other person to be psycho.

tgJuly 3rd, 2010 at 10:26 am

I meant to say “the former being much common” in my first paragraph. Sorry for typo.

NayNayJuly 3rd, 2010 at 9:13 pm

I can’t believe how many of you are crying “fake” over this post. Obviously you’ve all been spared the wrath of the fire-and-brimstone set, because I can definitely see this happening in real life.

SophieJuly 4th, 2010 at 2:47 pm

Sorry, but I just don’t buy it. I think it’s a fake as well.

SophieJuly 4th, 2010 at 2:52 pm

I should clarify. You know why I think it’s a fake? Because there aren’t many who would have intercepted him. Why do I say this? Because about a year ago a friend and I were walking in an open market one day in Chicago and as we neared the exit gate a homeless man yelled something at the two of us. We both ignored him and continued walking until he came up behind my friend and beat the shit out of her while I tried to yank him off (he was tall and big). I was yelling for someone to help us but everyone in the market just watched and surrounded the three of us like spectators. I managed to call the cops after he took a run for it and they found him four blocks away. My point it, it’s rare someone would have stopped him…it’s even rarer someone would have stopped him a second time.

TronnerJuly 4th, 2010 at 7:36 pm

You think it’s fake because of a personal anecdote? That’s pretty weak

TronnerJuly 4th, 2010 at 7:40 pm

@tg. My whole point WAS to create a ridiculous hypo as you were asking how I felt if the facts were completely different. My issue was, that no matter how you alter the facts, this wasn’t exactly an open and shut case if assualt by the OP

TronnerJuly 4th, 2010 at 7:41 pm

“of” assualt

AeonAugust 20th, 2010 at 8:39 am

I can totally see this happening. When I was college I met a nice guy who seemed super awesome: smart, funny, cute, etc. We hung out for most of a day moving folks into their rooms at college, so any chat was limited to major, things we do for fun and the like.

He asked me out on a date and invited me to be his friend on facebook so we could work out the details. Turns out, he’s a super – christian saving himself for marriage and only dates those he plans on marrying. Oh and his wife-to-be had better be as pure as the driven snow.

One of my facebook pictures was of me kissing a guy friend on the cheek. I swear to you, no pictures of drinking, rubbing all up ons, wild dancing or anything of the sort. Just me hugging a dear friend and giving him a peck on the cheek. Said picture was printed out and brought to our “date” and i was called a “slut” and a “whore” for “giving myself” to this man. Oh and I was screamed at for not telling our dear saint that I was a “fallen woman” and he wouldn’t have even considered being with me if he had known.

Being a young and immature 19 at the time, I burst into tears and fled with this guys shouting ringing in my ears. I wonder if this was the same guy. Talked to a pretty chick he liked, found out she had some (in his mind) illicit photos, and set out to shame her for her “dirty” ways. I do not understand how people can sanely twist their religions like that.

Leave a comment
Your comment