Plenty of Fish

It was the early nineties and six days into an apocalyptic break-up trauma, I had decided it would be good for me to date new people. I went on a date with a guy who had a five-year plan. He was pre-med at Stanford and there was a dream date quality about him. He took me to the pier for a nice stroll, a stellar choice had it not been the middle of winter. I didn’t bring a parka, nor did he offer me his coat. We reached the end of the pier where there was a fragrance of dead, scaled fishes. Although the stench was getting to me, I thought to myself, “Maybe this is what a dream date is suppose to be like?” Next he wanted to “wine and dine me at a really nice restaurant,” which were his precise words. My ex didn’t know that wine and dine could be used in the same sentence, so when he said it, I was grateful.

Yet, it was clear that the dream date Gods frowned upon me once we pulled in to the Denny’s parking lot. Inside bustled with screaming children, night shift workers and rowdy college kids. Oddly enough we were seated right away. Our table was tucked away in a dark corner, far from normal dining people. The busboy never came with waters. My date dominated the conversation; I spoke once to the waitress with a desperate plea for a side of ranch dressing. There was a fishy odor that had found a home in my cashmere sweater. I needed exit strategies. The bathroom window was an option, or even making a run for it and jumping into a cab or hitchhiking, I didn’t care.

So, I feigned a stomachache, blamed it on the ranch dressing and suggested he take me home. Easily enough he paid the check, which was a mere $12.95. My dream plan of escape was working, until he pulled into a parking lot of a 24-hour laundromat and a video rental store. I reminded him of my epidemic, but he reassured me that this would only take 10 minutes and it was on the way. After 20 minutes in the car, I couldn’t wait any longer so I went inside. The cashier at the counter immediately stared at me. As he was paying, I caught glance of one of the rentals, “All in the Sex Family” marked with triple XXX. I envisioned the subject header of tomorrow morning’s mass email to my single girlfriends: “He pit-stopped to pick up porn.”

I shaved my legs for this? 
 The car pulled up to my house and with a foot already out the door, he grabbed my hand and asked, “Want to do this again next week?” His hand cupped mine, underneath were his porn rentals.

“I might throw up.” I said.

I couldn’t risk his lean-over for a goodnight kiss, so I bolted. Years later, I laugh at myself now and have stayed away from guys with a five-year plan.

Comments (25)
SteveAugust 13th, 2010 at 8:09 am

Let the Man Bashing Begin!

that guyAugust 13th, 2010 at 8:10 am

So, you’re happy he was a pre-med student ($$$$ amirite?) yet you frown when he probably is broke that Dennys is the only place he could afford. Sounds like you set yourself up for failure because he was broke

tronnerAugust 13th, 2010 at 8:16 am

Man bashing? God I hope not…this little prick wasn’t a man. He sounds more like a little boy playing dress up. “Ok, my mom says a date should have a long walk along the beach: Check! A fancy dinner: Check! A film that everyone can enjoy: Check!”

Why did it take him 20 minutes to find “All in the Sex Family”? Were “The Jeffersluts” and the “Mary Tyler Whore Show” checked out already?

tronnerAugust 13th, 2010 at 8:19 am

@ that guy – he could only afford Denny’s yet he also could afford a stack of video porn? Yeah – this guy was just cheap and sleezy- not broke.

emAugust 13th, 2010 at 8:19 am

I don’t think she judged Denny’s/the guy for being cheap, I think she commented on it because when a guy says that he wants to “wine and dine” someone at “a nice restaurant”, Denny’s doesn’t exactly fit that description.

I SO want to pick up an email from a girlfriend entitled “he pit-stopped to pick up porn” — that would pretty much make my week.

JJAugust 13th, 2010 at 8:44 am

My new favorite answer to “want to do this again?” is “I might throw up”.

AndrewAugust 13th, 2010 at 9:32 am

I think I will just use, “I might throw up” for anything I don’t want to do.

I also didn’t think she was being judgmental for him taking her to Denny’s in the first place. It seemed like it was mainly about the disappointment she had because “wining & dining” sounds a little bit nicer than a dang Denny’s.

SarahAugust 13th, 2010 at 10:18 am

I agree with Em. And the fact there are many inexpensive restaurants that do not happen to be Denny’s. Gross.

ThandiAugust 13th, 2010 at 10:29 am

I don’t know what I like more, the way the OP comes across, the style of writing, or the actual bad date :) either way OP, send me a copy when you decide to turn this into a book, I loved reading it!

fatsAugust 13th, 2010 at 12:25 pm

Some of you girls seem so pathetic when you dislike a guy for wanting to go to an affordable restaurant and not some fancy place that you feel you deserve. I wouldn’t spend a lot of money on a first date. It’s a stupid thing to do.

tronnerAugust 13th, 2010 at 12:50 pm

Dennys on a first date is pathetic. I’m sorry. Especially after a statement like “I’m going to wine and dine you.” More like I’m going to Wine [Cooler] and Dine[r] you. (ok, that was admittedly bad). I don’t spend a lot of money on a first date, but I generally go to places that are a bit out of ordinary. Maybe nicer, certainly not a chain. Certainly not a chain that has “moons over my hammy” as an entree. It’s the smart thing to do.

tronnerAugust 13th, 2010 at 12:51 pm

Oh, and Denny’s is also out for breakfast the next morning…

JillAugust 13th, 2010 at 2:37 pm

@fats and that guy: So you’re both men, then?

I think it’s been explain over and over why she got mad/annoyed at being taken to Denny’s. Not all women are money grubbing whores. All we ask is for a little forethought, and also to not refer to Denny’s as a “really nice restaurant.”

StaceyAugust 13th, 2010 at 3:15 pm

Eeew, Dennys. Come on. Even getting fast food to go and eating it in a quiet, scenic location would be more romantic than that. Also, porn on the first date, especially when your date says she’s been feeling really ill? Yuck.

buffyAugust 13th, 2010 at 3:19 pm

tronner, you always hit the proverbial nail on the head. And make me laugh.

pkAugust 13th, 2010 at 6:49 pm

Ugh, Denny’s? I never minded a date at an inexpensive restaurant, but Denny’s is like the bottom of the barrel (okay to eat there occasionally, just never for a date). Plus, this date description with the porn stop was hilarious! Love the “I might throw up” at the end of the date LOL, too funny!!

rawrAugust 13th, 2010 at 8:12 pm

@that guy: Premed student tends to = poor as shit from paying for education (especially at a private university).

Also: Wine and dine =/= Denny’s. Denny’s isn’t fucking food.

lunaAugust 14th, 2010 at 1:51 am

I prefer to pay for my own meals on dates, so cheap places are just fine with me, but Dennys? No way.
But I think the nail in the coffin was the porn pitstop. I don’t even know what I’d say to that. “Uh…so you’re all set for porn then?”.

KellyAugust 14th, 2010 at 6:24 am

Oh man, my boyfriend and I always joke that he’ll take me to a fancy place, like the Olive Garden. I think I’ll tell him tonight that we should go someplace even fancier than the Olive Garden and suggest Denny’s. Awesome.

LAugust 14th, 2010 at 8:59 am

Does Denny’s even have wine??
Porn pitstop and “I might throw up” = priceless!

DuncanAugust 14th, 2010 at 12:48 pm

“I laugh at myself now and have stayed away from guys with a five-year plan.” – I like it all except the conclusion. I’m not sure the take home lesson here is ‘planning is bad’. If anything – not knowing what the pier is like at the time of year of the date, not having realised Denny’s doesn’t equate to fine dining and not… got his porn some other time – suggests a chronic /lack/ of planning.

“…guys with a five-year plan.” – OP’s date, Stalin, Mao, Ceauşescu… history has taught us that men with 5 year plans are often problematic.

TMSAugust 14th, 2010 at 8:12 pm

Promising to wine and dine someone and then taking them to Denny’s is like promising to take someone to a concert, and taking them to a karaoke bar instead. As for the porn pitstop, how in the hell does anyone even think for a second that that is acceptable, especially on a first date? I mean, it’s not acceptable on any date (at least none that I’ve ever heard of), but on a first date, it kind of gives off the impression that this guy had one thing and one thing only on his mind.

Frau BlucherAugust 15th, 2010 at 10:27 am

one of those guys who sound great in theory and then….
we don’t have Denny’s here, but even if you don’t have a much money, it does not sound like some place to take a first date: screaming children? uh no. There are plenty of ways to have fun on the cheap. Geez, we have great restuarants in chinatown that aren’t much more expensive than Denny’s!

I think stopping for porn should be a definite first date no-no, but since you weren’t interested, he probably figured he’d go home and whack.

ohpleaseAugust 16th, 2010 at 6:31 am

I always get a kick out of the whiny d00ds who immediately resort to misogyny to cover up the fact that they are losers. Yeah, clearly the OP is a gold-digging whore (which, I’m sure, all women are to “fats” and “that guy”), because the date promised one thing and delivered another. Silly golddiggers and their expectations that their date be honest!

Note to d00ds: when you do that, it communicates to all women around you that *you* are like the date too. Yes, we can see right through you.

LOL.

BriAugust 17th, 2010 at 6:17 am

While I know most college students are poor, I have to agree that taking someone to Denny’s on a first date is not appropriate. And I actually like Denny’s. I went there a lot in college, and I remember it being somewhere to hang out with friends. I think if the OP had been dating him for a while, or if they had hung out as friends for a while, this wouldn’t be as big a disappointment. But when you first start dating someone, you expect them to want to impress you a little bit. If he doesn’t he probably thinks he’s doing YOU a favor by going out on a date with you.

This guy doesn’t strike me as going to Denny’s because he was poor. He took her to Denny’s because he was too thoughtless to think of anywhere besides the local hangover joint, and a little self-centered. That’s why he took her somewhere cold without noticing she didn’t have a coat. It’s also why he dominated the conversation.

Leave a comment
Your comment