One “Cool” Dude

I had signed up for an online dating site for laughs, but found a few normal guys were sending me e-mails. One guy seemed normal (isn’t that how these all start), and he was very patient and polite when sending me e-mails.  He hadn’t lived here long, would like to take things slow, and wanted to meet for coffee at the place of my choosing.  After actually agreeing to give him my number, we spoke for two weeks before I felt we should meet in person.

I arrived a bit early, ordered a coffee, and waited.  W arrived, introduced himself, and we started a pretty normal conversation.

Toward the end is when it veered into slightly weird territory.  ”What shoes are you wearing?” W asked.

“Uh, just my normal black heels” I said, holding out my foot for him to see.

“Very pretty.”

I knew what was probably hiding behind that comment, but I wasn’t going to dig any deeper. Things seemed fine, but I wasn’t sure if there were sparks or not. I wasn’t ruling them out, but it wasn’t easy to tell what he was thinking.

I had snagged a spot right outside, so I told him I’d take him to his car a few blocks over.  When we got there, I was suprised that he leaned in for a kiss, since nothing in our conversation had really been flirtatious.  I responded, and we exchanged a bit of affection back and forth.

Then he said, “Why don’t you come over?”

“No, thank you.”

“You can have the bed,” he said.

“What???”  I was really confused because: 1) I didn’t know how a few kisses suddenly gave him an opening to have
me sleep with him, and 2) I could “have the bed”??? huh???

“I don’t want you thinking I”m trying to sleep with you. I don’t want to sleep with anyone for a while. It’s just my thing right now. But I really want you near me. You can stay over this weekend, and you can have the bed.”

“Uh, thanks, but that’s not something I’m even going to consider. You are still a complete stranger”.

He really seemed truly hurt, as though we were close close friends and he was never going to see me again.  Truth was, he probably wasn’t going to see me again.

“If you change your mind, you are welcome, I’ll give you directions…” and he proceeded to give me exact directions to his
home. Then he just sat in my passenger seat.

“Well, thanks for the meet up. Drive safe,” I said.  He didn’t move.

“I really should go. I’m going to meet a friend for dinner…” I said. Not a lie.

He leaned in for obviously another round of kissing, but I leaned back and just smiled at him.  ”Thanks. Drive safe.”

“You have the most amazing lips. I just don’t want to be away from them. I want you near me.  We can just hang out.” His pleading went from semi-lustful, to sentimental and back. And he seemed to actually be real about it. It didn’t seem like an act, but there was no way I was interested either way. He really needed to figure out what he wanted.

He FINALLY got the hint and got out of my car, but then he motioned me to roll the window down.  ”Goodbye, Lovely. It was an amazing experience. I will be seeing you soon.”

“Thanks. Have a good night” I said.

He left me with a “Later, dude.”

More than a week went by before I got a text from him.  ”Yo, hay, wuts up. its *W*. just sayin heeeey.”

Oookay.  I am fond of proper grammar whenever possible, and this also wasn’t at all like any of the messages or letters he’d sent me before.  I responded saying I was fine, and left it at that.

A few nights later, I got a phone call from W. “Hi. Hooowwwww arerrrrrr youuuu?”  He was obviously drunk.

I’m usually the oracle of dating wisdom for all my friends, and I’ve repeatedly said “Do NOT take drunk calls from guys.” Did I listen to my own advice? NO.

“I just wanted to hear your voice. How are youuuu? I really miss you.”

“I’m fine, you’re drunk, and I’m going to go.”

“PLEASE don’t go. I need a friend”

“What do you want?”

“I smell like Lime Coolada”.

“Uh, what?”

He proceeded to ramble on about how lonely he was here, and how he should never have moved here. I just sat there saying things like “uh huh” and “okay” every once in a while. WHY I stayed on the phone, I do NOT know. I could have saved myself the next part.

“What kind of nail polish do you have on?” W asked.

“What?”

“What kind of nail polish do you have on? What color?”

“It’s just pink nail polish.”

“Good. Never wear red. Red means you’re Tim’s girl. NEVER wear red.”

“Oookay then.”

“Tim is the one who stole Maria. I went away for a year, and he stole her.”

Great, a guy who drunk dials me to cry about his ex.

“I mean, I broke up with her, but I really loved her. I was gone, and she met him, and when I came back, they were engaged and living together, and she was wearing RED nail polish on her toes. That means she was his girl now.  I told her I’d take her back, and she still wants to marry him. SERIOUSLY”.

“I’m going to go now.”

“Would you PLEASE come over here. I won’t do anything to you. I’m not even interested in you anyway, you are way too white and aren’t the least bit Mexican looking. THOSE are the hot girls. And you’re too meaty. I have NO interest in you. We could just make out. But only if you’ll wear high heels. I won’t make out with a girl who isn’t wearing high heels. Might as well make out with a lesbian. It’s gross.”

(Note that he saw multiple pictures of me before meeting me, so he knew I was a size 14 white girl. And yeah…I didn’t “look Mexican.”)

“Gee, thanks. On that note, I’m going to hang up.”

“Whyyyyy?”

“Because you are drunk and rude. Do not call me again”.

“Come over. I smell like Coooooolada!!! Lime Cooooolada!!!! Please please please!!!”

“Goodbye” I hung up.

I never personally spoke to W again, but over the course of the next month, I got numerous texts and calls, all referencing “Lime Coolada,” and all obviously written while drunk.

“Hey, it’s W. I’m sitting at home drinking by myself all weekend. I’m lonely. I could use a friend. I smell delicious…like LIME COOOOLADA!!! HAHAHAHA. Call me back.”

Text: Smell like Lime Coolada right now. Smells so good. If you want to hang, I could use ‘my’ friend  (yeah, it went from “a friend” to “my friend” at some point)

“Heeeeyyy, it’s W. I’m scared you may have lost my number, so I’m just checking. You wanna come see my place yet? I could use my friend today. Call me. I smell like Lime cooooolada. You could smell me, if you want.”

Comments (22)
DeniDDecember 28th, 2011 at 5:25 am

Wow. Just…wow.

cupkateDecember 28th, 2011 at 7:46 am

This is hilarious because lime coolada is a type of lotion so this drunk freak was crying and rubbing lotion on himself all night in between harassing the OP. How much do you want to bet he was wearing stockings?

blondieDecember 28th, 2011 at 8:21 am

When it comes to online dating, I’m always a fan of meeting as soon as possible, with no phone conversations and minimal emailing/texting. You never get a real sense of a person until you meet them. OP talked to this dude for several weeks before realizing he was weird, which was a collasal waste of her time AND probably gave her date the idea that they were closer than they were.

LiLoDecember 28th, 2011 at 10:07 am

@cupkate I was about to point out the same thing! Hah! I vote for wearing stockings and heels.

DeeDecember 28th, 2011 at 11:12 am

Just be glad you WEREN’T wearing red nail polish. Can you imagine the torrent he would have unleashed upon you then?

courtneyDecember 28th, 2011 at 12:45 pm

@blondie I’ve always felt the same with online dating. I totally agree about getting a real sense of the person.
“I have NO interest in you. We could just make out.” “You could smell me, if you want.” I would have been so happy to have answered the phone if I were the OP, that one call and future texts make for great stories to tell forever.

NattieDecember 28th, 2011 at 2:08 pm

It puts the lotion on the skin….

@Cupkate – definitely makes the story creepier to know that it was a lotion he was referencing, not a drink. The latter would have made him seem like he drinks a bit too much, but the latter makes me think of Buffalo Bill.

That said, I’m totally writing down those texts, and sending them to the next guy who’s too persistent. Or maybe they’re not as creepy/hilarious when coming from a girl…

RavenDecember 28th, 2011 at 2:08 pm

This guy was so pathetic I actually feel kind of bad for him. Mostly I feel bad for OP, but there’s some compassion in there for Lotion Boy.

:/December 28th, 2011 at 3:29 pm

geez, i’m usually polite to a fault, but the minutes he started insulting me, i would’ve hung up and called my phone service to change my number. what a jerk, and a weirdo. :/

BeckZombieDecember 28th, 2011 at 8:34 pm

Oh god, I couldn’t stop laughing at all the lime coolaaaaadddaa texts and voicemails.

DuncanDecember 29th, 2011 at 12:49 am

“Good. Never wear red. Red means you’re Tim’s girl. NEVER wear red.”

I don’t know why, but this strikes me as the most intriguing part of the story. Did you ever find out who or what Tim is? Did he seem to be telling a joke or did he strike you as earnestly believing their was a Tim out there claiming women with his nail polish. Was there any context in the previous correspondence? I mean, what the heck?

TillDecember 29th, 2011 at 7:52 am

Damnit, Nattie beat me to the “It puts the lotion on the skin” joke.

blondieDecember 29th, 2011 at 8:26 am

Duncan- I think Crazy Boy explained who Tim was pretty clearly in the next few lines of the conversaion.

SnizDecember 29th, 2011 at 8:35 am

What, you don’t paint your women’s toes with your own special color of nail polish? How will the other men know to whom your woman belongs?

DeeDecember 29th, 2011 at 11:23 am

I change my nail polish weekly, and my nails and toes never match. Guess I’m just a big ol slut.

BackwoodsDecember 29th, 2011 at 4:26 pm

And she’s watchin’ him with those eyes
And she’s wearin’ that red polish,
I just know it
Yeah and he’s rubbin that lime coolada
On her arms late, late at night

I wish that I had Tim’s girl
I wish that I had Tim’s girl
Where can I find a woman like that?
(checks online dating sites)

Dr.CheeseDecember 29th, 2011 at 4:50 pm

*Jerry Seinfeld voice* “Whats the deal with lime colada”

C D PlayneDecember 30th, 2011 at 12:55 pm

HAHAHAHAAHAHA!!! Absolutely hilarious! Thanks for the needed laugh (while slathering on the Lime COOOOO-LAAAA-DAAAAA).
:}

MagsDecember 30th, 2011 at 1:37 pm

Guys, you are all hilarious. My sister wore the Lime Coolada lotion, so it made it that much weirder thinking about him wearing the same lotion as her. Excusing everything else, I still wouldn’t want to date someone who smelled like my sister.

Apparently he was really broken up over some girl HE broke up with who moved on, and he actually tried to break up her wedding plans. Why I attract this type of man, and why they choose me to spill their “I lost the love of my life” stories to, I do not know. I don’t solicit this type of discussion, but I still get it.

This was probably the most entertaining terrible date situation I’ve had, and despite his insults I don’t look back on it with anything but deep, satisfying laughter.

I think blondie has a point about meeting sooner rather than later. I kept thinking I’d feel more comfortable “getting to know someone” first, but you can get a better sense of who they actually are in person, and decide if they are someone you actually WANT to get to know. Most people give a better act on the phone than in person. I think I’ll take that approach next time…if there is a next time.

anonymousDecember 31st, 2011 at 7:44 am

Huh. Now I want to smell some Lime Coolada. THIS meaty white girl paints her toenails whatever color she wants because NO man “OWNS” me. Currently they are painted beige “Skinny Dippin’ in Lake Michigan” with a dollar store gold overglaze.

EmilyJanuary 3rd, 2012 at 4:06 am

It’s interesting to hear people talk about how meeting up sooner rather than later can help to stop you wasting your time on weirdos. However, I tend to find that meeting up with someone I find out I don’t get on with, is a bigger waste of my time and money than writing a message or replying to a text. Not a lot of my time goes into those things and because I’m a big fan of multi-tasking I’m usually doing something else at the same time (travelling to work, watching TV, playing a game etc). I’d have rather wasted some time writing out messages to people than wasting an entire day / afternoon / evening out with someone who I suddenly find I’m not going to click with. I guess you never know for sure till you’re face to face though, but I think I’ve avoided a few weirdos by chatting to them for a while online first!

Dr_KnowJanuary 21st, 2012 at 7:41 am

I think there is a balanced approach you need to take Emily – chat for a little while (like a week or two) and then meet up. If they haven’t revealed their weirdness through text within that time I doubt that they would ever show it.

Leave a comment
Your comment