Getting Lucky

My Very Worst Date didn’t actually seem absolutely bad until after the fact – but it certainly didn’t go that well.  I met a guy at a bar in college and we really hit it off.  I gave him my number and he called me later that week asking me to dinner.

He informed me that though his real name was Justin, he actually preferred to be called “Lucky” since he was redheaded and Irish.  Also this was his “club” name that everyone else knew him by.    I thought it was a little silly for someone who was 24 years old but I shrugged it off.  He then proceeded to tell me about how much he loved techno and how the only thing he looked forward to all year was going to Burning Man.  He wasn’t in school and was working in catering.  He quickly rebounded this by stating that he had been doing bigger and better things elsewhere, but had returned to the small town because his mother was suffering from breast cancer.  He said he had to spend a lot of his time taking her to doctor’s appointments and helping her out around the house.  I thought it was admirable he had made such sacrifices for his family.

After dinner he suggested going to my place since he lived with his mom and didn’t have a car.  I reluctantly agreed and we popped in a movie.  He didn’t waste any time with his advances as he was obviously not interested in the movie.  He kissed me and did the much dreaded tongue to the back of my throat.  After that I knew for certain I did not have an interest in this guy.

As it got later and the movie ended, Lucky asked if he could spend the night.  I gave him the sideways glance and he told me he really didn’t want to try anything and that he had work early in the morning.  For whatever reason I agreed and we both awkwardly slept in the same bed.   Of course, he tried something from time to time, but strangely enough, this little orphan kitten I had taken in a few days prior kept him from making his move.  Every time he tried something the kitten would playfully jump on his head and simply not leave him alone.

The next morning I woke up to him calling his work to say that he wouldn’t be coming in because he felt unwell.  He then gave me the eye and I told him I thought it was time for him to leave.  He did so a little bitterly and neither one of us called the other again.

A few weeks later my friend met his younger brother at a bar and, having heard my stories, asked how his mother was doing.  He looked at her baffled, saying that she was fine and wondered why she had asked.  She told him she had heard she’d been diagnosed with cancer – and to our horror, he revealed their mother never had cancer.  Lucky had moved back home because he ran out of money and needed a place to stay.

Comments (21)
JGirlJanuary 24th, 2012 at 10:04 am

I realize we all do unwise things from time to time, and I really try not to judge our OPs too harshly for those things, but you let the guy stay over? WTF?

NGJanuary 24th, 2012 at 10:20 am

Oh, how a cat can sabotage the love!

http://www.collegehumor.com/embed/6689920/cat-sabotages-love-life

amyJanuary 24th, 2012 at 11:16 am

Be careful taking in stray cats too. My friend did that and her whole family ended up with ringworm.

NattieJanuary 24th, 2012 at 11:41 am

Haha that’s adorable about the cat.

Letting him stay over does indeed seem strange, especially if you weren’t interested in sexytime (couldn’t he have slept in a guest room or on the couch?) but some people are used to sharing beds with their friends on such a regular basis, that it might not seem like a big deal.

NotCinderellJanuary 24th, 2012 at 1:15 pm

@NG the first time I stayed over at my now-husband’s apartment, his cat jumped on my face in the middle of the night while I was sleeping. 7+ years later, we’re still married and have added two more cats, but I think that there was some definite tension at first between me and the cat. He (the cat, not the guy) really felt like if I was going to join the pack, he and I were going to have to hash it out cat-style to figure out the pecking order. (I won, btw.)

ChelsJanuary 24th, 2012 at 1:38 pm

Dodged a bullet. But be a little less kind next time!

maoJanuary 24th, 2012 at 2:13 pm

I get that people will share beds with friends, but EVEN with friends, if you know that the other person will make some unwanted advances towards you, you would NOT have agreed to the bed sharing. The OP here ended up finishing the movie after the guy kissed her (unwanted) AND let him sleep in her bed with her, repeatedly attempt to do things (unwanted). OP, stand up for yourself and show him the door, you don’t owe him anything.

I love your kitty!

RavenJanuary 24th, 2012 at 2:55 pm

OP is Lucky (pardon me) that sleepytime didn’t turn into rapeytime.

Sharing a bed with a friend? Sure. Sharing a bed with a stranger? Stupid.

WenchJanuary 24th, 2012 at 3:25 pm

Grade A douchebag for lying about his mother having breast cancer.

Grade A+ kitty for jumping on the guys head all night. Cats are awesome.

And finally, the OP was an idiot for letting the guy sleep in her bed (and can thank her lucky stars she wasn’t assaulted). And yes, pun intended. Sorry, coudn’t resist.

LillithJanuary 24th, 2012 at 3:50 pm

yeah be sure to give that kitten some cream or catnip or something

NGJanuary 24th, 2012 at 3:54 pm

@NotCinderell: Congratulations on your victory over the cat! I’ve also heard stories about cats from my cat-lover friends that these animals do not particularly like the idea of sharing (space, food, affection). Probably this has got something to do with the fact that unlike canines, felines are mostly solitary animals. Apparently there’s a saying: “You don’t train a cat. The cat trains you.” As an aside, I recommend a highly entertaining story on cat-human relationship; this is called “Queen of the Jungle” by James Hynes, and can be found in the book “Publish and Perish.”

FranJanuary 24th, 2012 at 8:54 pm

“…and to our horror, he revealed their mother never had cancer. ” ?!!

I know you probably didn’t mean it this way, but possibly rethink the way you would formulate these things next time

Jacky MJanuary 24th, 2012 at 11:26 pm

@Fran: Lol, good point, I missed that!

Also I half-understand letting him stay over, if the alternative was driving him a long way home late at night, waking up his sick mother. But yeah, maybe the couch would’ve been more appropriate, the bed probably seemed to him to be an invitation to try things…

Some guyJanuary 25th, 2012 at 1:44 am

It’s worth noting that guys who use cheesy nicknames are often guys who consider themselves to be Pick-Up Artists (PUAs) as such names, especially referring to positive attributes like ‘Lucky’ are often used in the PUA community. I think some guys feel a greater sense of conquest if they are just known by their super PUA identity.

SallyWord!January 25th, 2012 at 9:38 am

Yay kitty!! I hope you kept her.

A friend of mine, many years ago, came to me telling me she’d met a great guy. He was so cool, he was known from around the clubs, a guy in his 40s who went around calling himself Smokey Bear. I told her to run. I begged her to run. She didn’t. What followed was violence, drugs, threats to her and her family with guns, and — of course — now she’s a single mother and he hasn’t been seen in years.

Never trust a man with a club name!!

Drinky the drunk girlJanuary 25th, 2012 at 12:27 pm

@Some guy, You hit the nail on the head. Now lets thank that Jameraqui hat, goggle wearing mother fucker for making losers think it’s cool to act that way. What a douche.

bloodyneptuneJanuary 25th, 2012 at 5:57 pm

I literally just spent the last year taking care of my mother, who had breast cancer. I cant imagine a lower human being then this guy right now.

GingergirlJanuary 25th, 2012 at 6:25 pm

Ha, never heard of someone getting pussy-blocked, but it happened!

AndrewJanuary 25th, 2012 at 10:44 pm

Love the kitten!

MollySueJanuary 26th, 2012 at 11:26 am

TEAM KITTEH!!!!

Also: “He informed me that though his real name was Justin, he actually preferred to be called “Lucky” since he was redheaded and Irish. ”
No he bloody isn’t. Any dumbass (ginger or otherwise) who tried that nonsense in Ireland would get their arse kicked. And rightly so. And if, by some unfortunate act of fate, he actually was born here – please keep him. We don’t want him back!

blondieJanuary 27th, 2012 at 9:14 am

Pussy blocked! Brilliant!

I’m with Molly Sue (though I’m not Irish). I get really annoyed with Americans who play up their 4% Irish bloodline when really their only interest in Ireland is beer-related. Ugh.

Leave a comment
Your comment