Impossible to Please

Ever since I broke up with my long term girlfriend, a female friend (who is a nurse at the University of Arizona’s hospital) was trying to set me up with one of her co-workers. I made excuses for a while because I just didn’t like the idea of dating again, but I finally gave in and my nurse friend said she was going to set up a double date: it would be herself, her boyfriend, me, and a nurse she worked with that I had to meet.

The night of the date, everyone met at my house because I live in walking distance to some good restaurants and bars. I did a lot of research, planning out the night so we had plenty of options and everyone could have a good time no matter what we decided to do. Keep in mind that this was my first real date since I met my ex (three years ago) so I was kind of nervous.

Once we got to the restaurant I picked, an Italian place, I was informed for the first time that my date was allergic to gluten. Meaning she couldn’t eat anything on the menu. But like I said, I had several choices picked out, including a Greek restaurant that would have gluten-free options and was right next door to the Italian restaurant. However, my date kept insisting we stay where we were. So we stayed there and it was the most awkward meal ever. Everyone just picked at their food while my date sat there with an empty plate. She was polite about it (for now) but you could tell everyone felt pretty weird.

After that we went to a bar a few blocks away. I got a drink for my date and myself and we all sat down. I asked my date if she was hungry and asked if she wanted to go somewhere else to get a bite (since we’d all had a meal at the first restaurant and she hadn’t eaten anything). She told me that she didn’t want to eat now because it was too late and she was on a diet. I said that I knew a place within a few blocks that had late-night hours and healthy options. My nurse friend backed me up because she’d been there too, but it seemed like my date just got more annoyed. The only thing she said was that she would appreciate it if I learned how to eat with a “real woman” for “future reference.” I had no idea what she meant but I felt like she was insulting me, so I looked at my female nurse friend. She and her boyfriend were staring at me with a look in their eyes like they felt sorry for me. That’s when I knew that this date was crashing and burning beyond repair.

The worst part is that the date lasted three hours longer from that point. My nurse friend and her boyfriend took a cab home and my date refused to go with them because they lived in the opposite direction. Instead, we sat in my living room for TWO MORE HOURS before she LET me call a cab for her. The entire time we were at my house, we sat on couch while she flipped through TV shows and said terrible things about everything on the screen, like “She’s so ugly, she should be shot” or “This show is so annoying, I can’t stand it.” She also kicked over and broke an Aboriginal vase that was a gift from my parents, which I wouldn’t normally be mad about except that she just giggled about it like she thought it was cute. I didn’t even expect her to apologize or help me clean up the clay shards, but laughing about it was the worst thing she could have done and I was really insulted and turned off.

What makes it even more weird is the next time I talked to my nurse friend, she told me my date that night claimed to like me and wondered why I never called her! Maybe I’m a really dense guy, but I still can’t think of any way I could have made this chick have a good time that night, or why she said she had a good time when she actually never stopped complaining!

Comments (24)
NGMay 21st, 2012 at 9:38 am

Does the OP have only reality shows?

S4R4HMay 21st, 2012 at 9:40 am

Sounds like your date thinks “real women” don’t eat. My bet is she’s A-OK to eat gluten, she just says she’s allergic to avoid eating with friends. Bullet dodged!

AudaxMay 21st, 2012 at 9:51 am

Stay away from the crazy, OP! Run! Run like the wind!

NattieMay 21st, 2012 at 9:59 am

Um yeah, sounds possibly eating disordered, definitely crazy… particularly with the vase-breaking. Bullet dodged. I’m a bit concerned that she’s a nurse… I hope she helps the ugly people, too.

sarahMay 21st, 2012 at 10:17 am

I feel like girls like this give all other girls a bad name.

Also, it seems like she has to have some redeeming qualities because why else would your friend be so adament about setting you up with her? That’s the part that is strange to me.

CatherineMay 21st, 2012 at 10:54 am

@ Nattie she maybe bi-polar or she has a work personality that is great but the outside of work one is awful. I am sure her co-worker may have never seen this side of her. Some people are like that. I had a co-worker who was a business bitch in the office than a big party girl and acted like your bff outside the office. I don’t care for people like that and stay far away from them.

TraceyMay 21st, 2012 at 11:26 am

I think I would’ve told that woman that 1) this date wasn’t working, 2) it was late, and 3) it would be best if she left long before the two hour mark in the living room. Then, I’d have a loooong talk with that friend about setting up dates for me again.

CarolynasaurusMay 21st, 2012 at 11:41 am

Shout out to the OP. First, points to you for having options. It’s got to be one of the worst first-date turn-offs when no one has any ideas of what to do. Secondly, I’m from that area and easily figured out all three restaurants you went to/suggested and those are three of the best places to eat! If she didn’t want to eat at any of them, she clearly has food issues.

KatyMay 21st, 2012 at 12:26 pm

Glad you found out about her early on. She’s seems to have some problems with her head.

buffyMay 21st, 2012 at 1:24 pm

Was her name Negative Nancy, or Debbie Downer, perhaps? Holy shit.

JGirlMay 21st, 2012 at 2:55 pm

I find it really difficult to believe that the restaurant didn’t have any salads or anything (fish?) on the menu that she couldn’t have eaten. She may have had to ask to have the croutons left off, but there should have been something.

I’m wheat sensitive myself, so I know that going to some restaurants can be an adventure, but I’v never been to a place where I couldn’t manage *something*. My guess is that to her a real woman doesn’t eat.

AppleMay 21st, 2012 at 3:05 pm

@Sarah, I think the friend was so desperate to set this crazy gal up with him because she knew he was such a nice and he might be able to handle her without flipping out and/or running immediately. Get crazy co-worker hooked up with not crazy awesome guy friend and hopefully she’ll mellow out in the work environment.
OP, you sound like a stellar guy and your awesome date was wasted on her. I sure hope the next I have is as fabulous as yours could have been w/o Miss Crazy!

AIPMay 21st, 2012 at 3:29 pm

I don’t believe for a second that there was “nothing” on the menu that she could’ve eaten if she wanted to. Even the crappest Italian can cobble together a Caprese salad, which incidentally is the food of the Gods. And speaking as a non-pretend woman, I’ve no idea what she was on about, but it’s unlikely to have been complimentary.

JackyMMay 21st, 2012 at 6:12 pm

Aw, poor OP. Seriously, that woman sounds like a nutjob… But did that restaurant really not have any salads, risotto or gluten-free pasta? She obviously just didn’t want to eat, and assumed you thought anorexia was anor-sexier…

belieMay 21st, 2012 at 8:29 pm

lol what a weirdo. sounds like she was just physically attracted to u & really didn’t care about ur feelings. also sounds like ur ‘friend’ wanted to get u laid cuz maybe u looked depressed from the breakup w/ur ex i suppose. next time just call her cab even if she takes offense, it’s ur house. at least she didn’t whip it out lol :P

jshawMay 21st, 2012 at 9:38 pm

If this story was written by a woman about a man the responses would be so completely different. Well done with the sexism, yet again.

DaveMay 21st, 2012 at 11:11 pm

I don’t catch your meaning, jshaw. The woman was a problem, and would have been as a man. Op did good. Handled politly and well. Also, some people can’t talk if they aren’t complaining. My sister and wife are like that. I just tune ‘em out when it happens.

ZtreMay 22nd, 2012 at 2:29 am

This made me laugh, because I myself am gluten free and always make sure to plan out my own meals or places where I can eat.
It takes no more than 10 minutes to call a restaurant to ask if they have anything gluten free on the menu.
The girl should have made her allergy known to OP beforehand when they planned out the night, and then been grateful that he was prepared to move to somewhere that does have gluten free food. I know I would’ve been!

NattieMay 22nd, 2012 at 6:20 am

@Catherine, good point, perhaps she’s so very tired of caring for people that she’s not very nice when she’s not at work. Bullet dodged, anyway.

SallyWordSlingerMay 22nd, 2012 at 6:47 am

I want to know why the friend wanted to set up her friend with such a shrew.

SallyWordSlingerMay 22nd, 2012 at 6:47 am

PS. That is a hideous vase.

maoMay 22nd, 2012 at 12:23 pm

I agree with other commentators that the nurse friend didn’t know about this ugly side of OP’s date, based on the fact that the friend seemed to be on OP’s side throughout the date. And I know people like OP’s date, and mostly using good allergies as an excuse, lecturing people about “eating healthy”, when they are basically refusing to eat at all.

OP, you did great. Stick with your instinct and ditch the crazies earlier next time :)

JeffMay 24th, 2012 at 3:46 pm

As I read this, at first I assumed the date was just reacting out of embarrassment, not wanting to put anyone to any trouble over her dietary restrictions. However, after reading the whole thing, I agree with S4r4h and Nattie – I think the gluten-free thing was just a beard for an eating disorder. Eating disorders often go along with control issues and I get the sense this woman had them in spades.

Also, is it me or is doing a first date as a double date usually a bad idea? It’s hard enough to be comfortable with someone on a first date without introducing the added pressure of two extra pairs of eyes and ears, even if (or especially if) they are mutual friends.

KGJune 21st, 2012 at 8:20 am

the OP seems like a really sweet guy. Not only did he have all these options, and even offer to buy her food AFTER everyone else had eaten, he also didn’t get mad about the vase until after she laughed. He seems like a good guy that I would want to date.

Leave a comment
Your comment