Birthday Breakup

Well, My Very Worst Date just took place about three hours ago. My boyfriend and I recently “celebrated” our six month anniversary. That was the plan, anyway. He called me early in the day and told me he was effusively sorry, but something came up, and we would have to do a rain check on our happy evening together. I didn’t protest, because he’s been a pretty stellar boyfriend up to now and to be perfectly honest, this didn’t raise any red flags with me. I trusted him.

Rain check happened the very next day, today actually. He came over to my house and acted completely normal, kissing my forehead with a “Hi, babe.” We sat on the sofa for a minute, not feeling the need to rush right out to our date, when he said, “I have a confession to make.” Intrigued, I told him to go for it.

He proceeded to tell me that nothing had actually come up on our anniversary, he was just “in a weird head space.” Lately he’s been wanting more and more freedom from the ties of a serious relationship. He said he’s been missing the ability to do whatever he wants, with whomever he wants, without a girlfriend around, and without a girlfriend he must consult with beforehand. This offended me because I’ve never required “consulting” and have been pretty damn supportive of his need for independence from me. I said this to him, and he didn’t contradict me. He agreed with me! I asked, “What’s the problem then?” He then gave me the “it’s not you, it’s me” speech.

Let me reiterate that this is coming COMPLETELY out of left field. We have no problems! We’re that disgusting couple that people roll their eyes at and secretly resent. He even said so himself, and admitted to me that he has no real explanation of why this conversation was taking place, or where this was coming from except that, “Maybe I’m mentally ill.”

We went round and round about his issues for hours. He wanted “time and space to explore his options” and he wanted to do what’s “in his best interests.” Then he started making a verbal pros and cons list of staying with me vs. not staying with me until I finally told him I can’t do this anymore and I can’t handle this on our anniversary of all days. I made up his mind for him and told him he needed to just go home, and thanks for a ‘lovely’ evening. He ended with, “So, this is over? We’re done?” I didn’t know what else to say besides yes. He couldn’t have made it any more clear that’s he’s one foot out the door already.

As he was leaving, a light bulb came on above his head and he said, “Oh, yeah. Happy Birthday.” That’s right. This night just so happened to be my 24th birthday. Amazing.

Comments (42)
zomboidJune 21st, 2012 at 4:46 am

so…you interrogated him for HOURS about why he was trying to break up with you?

TalJune 21st, 2012 at 5:00 am

At least he told you. Civilly. Even if it was random.

PsycheJune 21st, 2012 at 5:43 am

Ouch!

NikkiJune 21st, 2012 at 5:45 am

That really sucks, OP. I had a similar experience when the guy I was dating broke up with me. He told me that he was attracted to me, respected me, thought I was intelligent and funny and fun, but that “something just wasn’t right” and he didn’t know why but he had to break up with me.

Looking back, I’m sure he was telling me exactly what he was thinking, but at the time it felt like he was hiding something, and so it was a hard break-up to accept. His reasons didn’t feel like break-up reasons, they felt like “we can work through this” reasons. I can totally see why you didn’t want to let him off the hook so easily!

SynnoveJune 21st, 2012 at 5:51 am

You’re 24 and you celebrate six month “anniversaries”?

Also, the only reason one needs to give when they’re breaking up with you is that they want to. And would you really want to hear his answers anyway? Describing exactly what he didn’t like about you? He was trying to break up with you without being a total asshole.

RattusJune 21st, 2012 at 5:57 am

He didn’t love you, he didn’t see ever being in love with you. I think that is a legitimate reason for breaking up with someone, even if there are no quantifiable problems, and a legitimate reason to not want to celebrate a six-month (seriously?) anniversary. It is also a really difficult issue to describe if one is not fully aware that that is why they don’t wish to extend a relationship.

mhmmJune 21st, 2012 at 6:00 am

wow what a jerk. tho, i doubt u were the ‘perfect’ couple, every relationship has it’s problems. don’t mean to rub salt in your wounds, but it sounds like he alraedy has found someone else he wants to date instead. :\

NattieJune 21st, 2012 at 6:15 am

Basically what Rattus said. Sometimes there isn’t an obvious reason why someone wants to end a relationship – maybe it’s true that he actually just missed being single even though you weren’t a clingy girlfriend. And honey – if a guy wants to break up with you, let him. If he isn’t crazy about you, you’re both wasting your time.

Although I’m sorry that he did that to you on your birthday.

TillieJune 21st, 2012 at 6:29 am

I’m going to have to go with the general consensus here so far. Six month “anniversary”? A post-breakup interrogation session? Yikes and double yikes.

I’m sorry you got dumped on your birthday, that’s pretty craptastic. But did you really want to wait another 3 months until your “3/4 of a year anniversary” only to find it wasn’t going to work out? Better sooner than later.

SallyWordSlingerJune 21st, 2012 at 7:01 am

That was boring. I’m about ready for a new “and then he took it out” story. It seems like ages.

AwesomeIDJune 21st, 2012 at 7:03 am

Yeah – let’s get a good wang story going! :)

NikkiJune 21st, 2012 at 7:07 am

Did it say that she was interrogating him? Maybe they just had a long midst-break up conversation hashing out their issues. They’re also painful, stetched-out and awkward but they happen. She makes it sound like he was still working out why he wanted to break up with her too.

KJune 21st, 2012 at 7:17 am

The something that came up was his penis. The other options he wanted to explore were brave new places to put it in. He was just too chicken shit to admit it. You’re better off.

TechimpairedJune 21st, 2012 at 8:15 am

When did this become the “my very worst long term relationship” site? Is it just me or have there been more and more of these stories from people who didn’t so much have a bad date as a bad relationship? More often than not these stories are just sad and pathetic and really not about an actual date. Is anyone filtering these stories anymore or is everything and anything getting through?

LiLoJune 21st, 2012 at 8:34 am

@sallywordslinger

I’m with you.

JayJune 21st, 2012 at 8:39 am

Fairly normal breakup, I think.. At least until the “Happy birthday” part.

RavenJune 21st, 2012 at 8:42 am

This was harsh, but (I guess) at least it was face-to-face, instead of facebook-to-facebook.

Also, for the haters out there – what’s wrong with celebrating six months together? Sure, it’s not “officially” a real anniversary, if you want to get nitpicky, but there’s nothing wrong with celebrating love (or lust!). Yeesh.

It was mean of him to do it on her birthday, and I’m sending OP a big hug. Sometimes, even though the person you’re with is great, something just isn’t right. At least he didn’t drag it out and make it worse. I hope you find someone great, OP!

MargaretJune 21st, 2012 at 8:58 am

I think anyone celebrating “six month anniversary” is not mature enough for a real relationship anyway.

GinnyJune 21st, 2012 at 9:02 am

Oh yuck – he could have spared her the pro/con list and actually just, you know broken up with her and let her know clean and simple that he just wasn’t sure about the whole thing anymore. It isn’t the nicest thing to hear, or the easiest thing to say, but putting someone through the wringer is kind of cruel.

I third the need for a good wacky wang whipout story! This stuff just makes me roll my eyes.

blondieJune 21st, 2012 at 9:18 am

Meh. This sounds like every single normal breakup ever. Even the birthday/anniversary thing is totally normal. People get freaked out around holidays and special days because that’s when it’s really driven home that there’s supposed to be something special there, but there isn’t. It’s why people keep getting dumped right after Christmas, weddings, etc.

Oh, and ditto Margaret! 6 months? WTF.

YannickJune 21st, 2012 at 12:40 pm

Why not a six month monthaversary? It’s fun!

Quit being so rigid, jeez.

NellyJune 21st, 2012 at 1:40 pm

So he broke up with you. Boo hoo hoo. Big deal. Newsflash: You are not the first person to go through this. Get over it and get on with your life.

PS: Are you really 24? You sound like you are 16.

Bananas in PyjamasJune 21st, 2012 at 1:59 pm

Hi OP, i don’t think there’s ever a good time or a perfect way to breakup with someone (although I think face to face is the most noble way for which I’m pleased this guy did) but On your bday was bad timing.

I think the fact u sent in this entry so soon after u broke up shows how raw with emotion u still r. As such u haven’t had time to reflect to put it into perspective. I know hurt is subjective and I’m sorry it hurting but this is a close to a normal breakup. U’ll come to see that in time.

Hope u will feel better soon.

XandrayaJune 21st, 2012 at 2:25 pm

I just broke up with my boyfriend of 2 years and he pulled the same shit you did. I told my boyfriend, as your boyfriend told you, that it was over. Just let it go. Rehashing it or going into details will only hurt your feelings further. I know being dumped sucks and you felt blind-sided, but move on.

AvidReaderJune 21st, 2012 at 2:39 pm

I know I’m generally in the minority in this, but it’s better that he broke up with her on her birthday than letting her realize he didn’t want to be celebraing with her afterwards. At least OP could then call up some girlfriends and go make her night better.
Also, if I was with someone who wanted me to celebrate a six month “anniversay”, I’d want some space, too.

WiccaJune 21st, 2012 at 3:45 pm

Sweetie, he’s just not that into you. And he’s probably sniffing around someone else’s knickers right about now. Crack open the tequila, call your girlfriends, get white girl wasted and have some FUN.

MaryJune 21st, 2012 at 4:16 pm

What is this? My very worst breakup? lol.

JeffJune 21st, 2012 at 5:09 pm

Other than taking place on your birthday – which I agree was poor timing on his part – this isn’t even a particularly bad breakup, much less a VWD. My first LTR partner dumped me over the phone after we’d been together for two years by telling me she’d been cheating on me with another guy.

AmberJune 21st, 2012 at 6:17 pm

All of you ripping on celebrating six months together – what’s wrong with celebrating six months together? To some people, these events are very special; who are you guys to say how (and how often) other people should celebrate? Some people celebrate their babies reaching 100 days – do you go and tell them how stupid and juvenile they are too?

That said, OP – I hope you realize that this was a blessing in disguise. This guy would have hurt you eventually, and it’s better that he did it sooner rather than later.

fungs2June 21st, 2012 at 8:19 pm

I honestly reckon this guy simply didn’t want to buy a present for anniversary or birthday especially when it’s so close together. I guess being a jerk was easier than buying a present?

really?June 21st, 2012 at 11:02 pm

I have to echo Nelly. I thought this was a teenage poster. A break up isn’t really a MVWD. I’m sorry that he broke up with you, but it didn’t really need to be posted here.

KCLeaJune 22nd, 2012 at 12:55 am

It sounds like he wants to be “free” from a relationship and wants to sleep around. He’ll miss you soon enough and come crawling back, they always do.

EdhlaJune 22nd, 2012 at 1:50 am

Wow, some pretty cruel comments here. Do you guys really expect a stellar, literary-prize-winning writeup from someone who’d been dumped three hours previously? If the story sucks, it’s the admin’s fault for putting it up at all. Harsh. Breakups suck.

europeanJune 22nd, 2012 at 6:16 am

I agree completely with Nelly

First thought: omg, young teen lovers making their first approach with reality….then came the 24th birthday

AndyJune 22nd, 2012 at 6:40 am

1. There’s no such thing as a “6 month anniversary.” 2. He was screwing around on you. 3. He sounds like a real d*ck and you are better off without him.

NellyJune 22nd, 2012 at 6:43 am

@Amber. Yes we do. You want to celebrate your babys 100days then fine. Just dont expect me to like it

RattusJune 22nd, 2012 at 7:56 am

@Amber. Who are you to tell what one should think is stupid and what one should think isn’t?

JGirlJune 22nd, 2012 at 11:58 am

If the details weren’t ever so slightly off, I’d really wonder if this had been written by my ex’s new girlfriend. This sounds like exactly the kind of thing he would do, but she’s older than that and they’ve been together about 8 months (it’s easy for me to know that because they got together so quickly after our breakup).

OP if that guy is anything like the Ex he reminds me of, you lucked out. Be happy he’s out of your life.

CJune 23rd, 2012 at 12:24 am

I was dumped the day before my 26th birthday. I was shattered. (No, it wasn’t for lack of a present; he actually broke down about a week prior, cried, and admitted he “didn’t know what he wanted.” I told him to take some time, think about it, and talk to me when he was ready. He was ready the night before my birthday. Yay me!)

Anyways, OP… yes, that was awful. **He** wasn’t particularly awful, though. Maybe that “perfect” relationship ended up feeling like a role he had to play? Maybe he’s 24 and in a suspended state of adolescence and finds commitment constricting? Maybe he’s interested in another girl? Maybe he thought you were dismissive about something seemingly minor, but is very important to him? Maybe you just aren’t IT, but he lacks the ability to tell you honestly and openly. There are a million options. Buck up. At least you only invested six months.

Also, endlessly questioning a guy as to why he doesn’t want to be with you is a bad choice. Always. Possibly, one of the reasons he’s leaving you is that you’re likely to question him as to why he’s leaving you. If you want clarification on a point, you should get it. (Ex: the “consulting with a girlfriend” thing. If he says some b.s., feel free to call him on it.) If you want him to detail why he doesn’t love you? You’ll suffer regardless of the outcome.

UnsightlyJelloJune 24th, 2012 at 8:21 pm

You don’t happen to live in Missouri near St. Louis do you? This sounds familiar….

lastpoemJune 26th, 2012 at 9:01 pm

This same crap happened to me (minus the birthday part). It’s not good stuff.
I bet he wanted to talk about his issues ans she wasn’t the one enquiring.

EJuly 15th, 2012 at 5:34 pm

Wow, I had a very similar experience, though honestly I sort of did see it coming. He had been acting somewhat distant in the days preceding the breakup. During the breakup, he was bawling like crazy. That’s the part that shocked me the most, since we had only been dating for about three months or so.

Leave a comment
Your comment