A Sharp Mood Kill

Most of the posts that I read on here are about how MVWD can be blamed on the other person. In this case, I’m pretty sure that I was, inadvertently, someone else’s Very Worst Date.

I had been divorced for about two years, and was fully enjoying dating in my mid 30’s. I had been on two very promising, successful dates with “D”. The first date had been drinks and we ended up talking for three hours. The second date had been the Ferry Building Farmer’s Market in San Francisco, and we walked and talked, ate fruit and bread, and enjoyed the amazing view of the bay. It was a really good time, and I sensed that she’d had fun as well. It was D that made the plans for the third date, the following Saturday night. She was excited about meeting my dog as she really liked Labradors. I suggested that she stop by my house and play with my dog a little bit, before we headed out to the restaurant that she wanted to try. D thought that was a great idea.

It was the Saturday night before Thanksgiving, and she was due to arrive at around 7:00. I had finished getting ready and had half an hour before she arrived. I did a quick check around the house to make sure there wasn’t anything incriminating lying around. I hid the bathroom reading material, I made sure that the bed was made in case she wanted to take a tour of the house, I sprayed some air freshener around the house (just in case) and still had 15 minutes to spare.

As I was hosting Thanksgiving for my family in the coming week, I figured that since I had some time to kill, I might as well sharpen my knives for Thanksgiving, so that I didn’t have to do it with my nieces and nephews running around when family came over. So I took out almost every kitchen knife that I had and started sharpening them on the kitchen island with my electric sharpener.

D was right on time and the doorbell rang 15 minutes later. She fell in love immediately with my dog, and they started playing in the living room. I told her that I’d pour her some wine and, when she was done messing around with the dog in the living room, to come into the kitchen, I just had to finish this project I was working on. I could hear her say something in the living room, but I couldn’t tell what she said as the knife sharpener was too loud. “Come in here” I yelled, “ I can’t hear you”

… As she walked into the kitchen, that’s when she saw them… every knife that I owned, sitting there on the kitchen island, laid out by size. (I’m very organized) From 12 inch chef’s knife, to the 8 inch boning knife. The LED lights from the light fixture over the island must have lit them up spectacularly.

She sort of stood there stunned for a second. I was completely clueless as to what that must have looked like to a woman I’d only met twice, and a woman who had never been in my  house before.  She stammered something about an emergency at home that she needed to get back to immediately, and left before I could even begin to find out what the problem was. I texted her a couple of times that night to see how she was doing, but there was no response.

Just before I went to bed, I walked to the kitchen island to put the knives away was when it hit me. I felt like a total moron. I never heard from her again. I emailed her an explanation but got no response.

Sorry D! I wasn’t thinking! I’m really not a psychopath, I swear.

Comments (28)
SallyWordSlingerJune 27th, 2012 at 7:28 am

Hahahahahaaaaaaa. Great story, Dexter.

Elly-RoseJune 27th, 2012 at 7:38 am

Aw, that’s pretty sad actually.

SmokeJune 27th, 2012 at 7:43 am

I was thinking more Paul Bateman. Good story though, I feel bad for the op!

DSpiroffJune 27th, 2012 at 7:49 am

I love this one. A great “I was clueless!” story. I am glad however that she had the good sense NOT to wait and find out what the knives were for!:) They may have been harmless, but I applaud a woman who found herself in that could have been a horrible situation and removed herself.

LiLoJune 27th, 2012 at 7:59 am

That’s pretty awesome. Kinda sucks for the OP, nut man that chick has a great bad date story to tell.

NatalieJune 27th, 2012 at 8:03 am

I thought this was really funny. Sounds like something my husband would do if he were in such a situation.

tronnerJune 27th, 2012 at 8:07 am

Probably not a good idea to leave that tarp, shovel, and bags of lye sitting on the sofa, either.

TraceyJune 27th, 2012 at 8:16 am

Remember the Ameriquest “Don’t Judge Too Quickly” commercials? The one where a guy was cooking dinner for his girlfriend, and it ended with a scene where it looked like he’d stabbed their cat? That’s what this made me think of.

Here’s a link if you don’t remember or never saw it: http://youtu.be/TylESgErsJI

So sorry, OP, and sorry she didn’t (ahem) cut you some slack when you tried to apologize.

NattieJune 27th, 2012 at 8:23 am

Bahaha.

I’m a bit confused as to why you would have continued on with the knife sharpening once she arrived, leaving her to play with the dog by herself instead of joining in. I’m also a bit confused why she was so afraid. Perhaps I’m completely lacking my “stranger danger” spidey senses, but a) knives in the kitchen are rather normal; b) it shouldn’t take a whole set of knives to stab someone; c) a roofie in the wine would be a far more likely danger; d) if you wanted to stab her you would have tried, an “emergency” excuse wouldn’t have saved her.

I hope you remembered to put your knives away on the next date, though!

ChelsJune 27th, 2012 at 8:25 am

Stories like this deserve the 5-star rating system. Made me laugh. Poor OP… heh.

NGJune 27th, 2012 at 8:29 am

@Nattie: Yes.

May be D reads/watches a lot of psycho-horror stuff.

AvidReaderJune 27th, 2012 at 10:02 am

Hahaha! I’m sorry, OP, but I feel like this is one story you’ll be able to laugh about eventually. That poor woman, I can only imagine what she was thinking! Although I do feel like she overreacted by not even calling you again after the explanation. It would seem perfectly plausible to me, honestly.

sarahJune 27th, 2012 at 10:06 am

This is hilarious but I agree that it was a bit of an overreaction on her part. I don’t think it was that big of a deal OP!

DeeJune 27th, 2012 at 10:22 am

Seems like a bit of overreaction… but then again, the Ted Bundy’s and John Gacy’s of the world seemed perfectly nice to their neighbors, too. If our first couple of dates had gone spectacularly, I would have stayed. Then teased you about your murderous intent mercilessly.

KryJune 27th, 2012 at 11:05 am

I can almost guarantee that I would have reacted in the same way D did. All those shiny knives just sharpened and laid-out with a glass of wine waiting for me? No thanks! Definitely has something to do with all the slasher movies I’ve watched.

Maggie MayJune 27th, 2012 at 11:12 am

Sorry, I’m with Nattie on this. It’s a cute story but rings completely false – why would he go back to sharpening knives once she arrived? It’s Saturday night and Thanksgiving isn’t until the following Thursday. It’s not as if he needs to finish this task before leaving for the date. So, yeah, I’d think it was odd if I were his date and he was “finishing a project” at a time when we agreed our date would start.

The story would’ve worked just as well, by the way, if he’d just gone into the kitchen to pour the wine and she followed him and saw all the knives. In fact, probably would’ve worked better, since then we wouldn’t be scratching our heads wondering who abandons his date to “finish a project” that has no urgency.

maoJune 27th, 2012 at 1:02 pm

Haha, this is such a cute story.

@Maggie May, Nattie has questions about OP’s date’s reaction, but she didn’t say the story was false. In my opinion, the date did overreact for a little bit. But even if they had 2 enjoyable dates, OP is still a stranger to her. It’s better to overreact and be safe than sorry, than give a total stranger the benefit of doubt, even though it sucks for the OP.

As far as the knife thing, OP sounds like the kind of person who’s REALLY organized and takes “always be prepared” to heart. He was ready 30 minutes before the date, double checked the house, and still had time to spare. That does sound consistent with someone who would think about sharpening knifes 5 days in advance, and also someone who would actually arrange knives by size when sharpening them. I think the reason he continued once his date arrived was probably along the same lines: he wanted to finish what he was doing and put all the knives neatly back where they belonged, before heading out.

That same overly-organized vibe could also be what his date sensed and set up alarm bells in her head.

S4R4HJune 27th, 2012 at 1:52 pm

@mao: “That same overly-organized vibe could also be what his date sensed and set up alarm bells in her head.”

Bingo!

TillieJune 27th, 2012 at 2:21 pm

This story was really well written. How Jeffery Dahmer of you!

yayknifesJune 27th, 2012 at 9:53 pm

yeah i would’ve been creeped out walking in a guy sharpening his knives, but not as creeped out as him in women’s clothes or something like that. sounds like an overreaction on the woman’s part. i would’ve at least waited a moment for an explanation…:/

NattieJune 28th, 2012 at 6:26 am

Yeah, I don’t really have an opinion as to whether or not this story is true. It does seem odd and a bit rude to ignore your date to go back to a chore, but it’s also understandable to want to finish something up – maybe he didn’t want to leave a knife half-sharpened.

And it’s fair enough for D to be scared – better safe than sorry, and she may have had an overactive imagination or just finished watching a horror movie the night before. I guess I just find the knives-in-kitchen thing so normal; just like if I found a shovel, an axe, and duct tape in someone’s garden shed, I wouldn’t think they wanted to kill me. That said – who knows, maybe it was his extreme organization skills that freaked her out more than the knives themselves.

AudaxJune 28th, 2012 at 11:14 am

o_O

Dude, you went _back_ to sharpening knives?

Obsess much?

CatherineJune 28th, 2012 at 11:23 am

Maybe she has a knife phobia. I think she should have given him the benefit of the doubt. In my mind he is the type of person who likes to finish what he started.

MaryJune 28th, 2012 at 11:45 am

I was just at the Ferry Building Farmer’s Market the other day! Small world!

KCLeaJune 29th, 2012 at 11:56 pm

She sounds kind of crazy and dramatic for running out for knives in a kitchen. I think the OP dodged a bullet here, there’s nothing wrong with organization or being prepared in advance.

NyanJuly 1st, 2012 at 11:58 pm

These comments amuse me. Imagine this story was from the woman’s perspective, that she had stayed instead of leaving, and the guy then turned out to be a total creep? Everyone would be bashing her for not fleeing the moment she saw the freshly sharpened and carefully lined-up collection of kitchen knives.

Herp derpJuly 3rd, 2012 at 1:26 pm

This is funny but really weird. Why would you keep sharpening your knives? Or, better yet, why would you remove ALL the knives, knowing full well your date was to arrive in fifteen minutes? I dunno, seems odd.

Also, I think that women completely overreacted. Yeah it’s good to air on the safe side, but she could have at least asked what he was doing, or responded to his texts. But nope, she just left and seemingly ignored his attempts to ask her what was wrong. I never understood why people do that (never give someone an opportunity to explain themselves).

That’s just my take.

JeffJuly 7th, 2012 at 10:40 pm

If the knives are all laying there in plain sight, the OP would have had to have been the world’s dumbest slasher. Seems to me two successful dates should have at least earned him the chance to explain what he was doing. On the other hand, maybe he gives off a creepy vibe even without the knives.

Leave a comment
Your comment