I Went On Her Date Too

It was several years ago, when the first Dark Knight movie hit theaters. One evening I got a text from a friend of mine, Alfred, asking if I wanted to go see the movie in IMAX that night. Excited, I agreed, and offered to drive. We were later than I wanted arriving to the theater; while the previews hadn’t started quite yet, a lot of the seats were already taken. Therefore, no matter where we sat, one of us would have to be next to a random stranger. We also had not had time to get food. Not a huge deal, only we had not eaten dinner and Alfred is something of a bottomless pit of skinny-boy hunger.

As we stood in the front of the theater contemplating our seat options, I felt my phone buzzing in my pocket. It was my best friend, Nadia. “I see you,” she said cryptically. “I’m in the back row of the theater! Come sit with us!” I looked towards the back, and there she was, sitting next to a shadowy figure, waving frantically. Alfred and I started up the stairs as I tried to figure out who Nadia was sitting with. Judging by the body type, it was a man, but from the distance and in the dark I couldn’t place him. I figured he must be one of her guy friends from work – Nadia was always going on and on about her work friends.

We arrived and quickly took our seats – I sat between Nadia and Alfred. I looked over at Nadia’s movie companion. He was no one I recognized. Now, I’m a rather outspoken girl – more so around and pertaining to Nadia. We’ve been best friends since I moved to town in 4th grade – that’s about 14 years, now. She is a little shy and way more of a people pleaser than I am, which has made it easy for a lot of her “friends” to take advantage of her. As you might imagine, it’s also affected her romantic life – seems like my constant line is “where do you FIND these guys?” because the men she has attracted are the most eclectic bunch of fellows I have met – but they tend to all be losers. It’s taken years for her to be able to emerge from her shell and stick up for herself. These days she is fine, but at the time I was extremely protective of her, and suspicious of people I didn’t know – which she invariably, to this day, thinks is awesome/hilarious.

I offer all this random extra information because, when I tell you all that I narrowed my eyes at Nadia’s date and said “Who are you? I don’t know you,” and that Nadia started cracking up, I don’t want all of you to think that we’re both horrible judgmental brats. It’s just the way we operate.

The strange guy looked a little taken aback, but introduced himself as John and actually countered by saying “I don’t know you, either. Who are YOU?” Score one for John – usually Nadia’s dates are men of few words and fewer brain cells. I shook his hand, saying “I am H. You don’t know me, but you will.”

The four of us chatted for a moment. Alfred mentioned his hunger and John offered him the remaining half of his dish of cheesy pretzel bites, claiming that he had bought too many refreshments and was full. While they negotiated that, I quietly asked Nadia how she knew this guy. She told me that he was a random customer who had walked up to her cash register at work and asked for her phone number. Admiring his forwardness, she had complied.

Then the movie started and we all sat back to watch it.

About twenty minutes into the movie, I turned to make a comment to Nadia to find that her face was attached to John’s. They stayed that way, noisly sucking face, for a quite a while. At least Alfred was there, but it was still supremely awkward to know that two people were making out directly next to me. Later, Nadia told me that he had just sort of swooped in and she went with it because she didn’t want to be rude (like I said, people pleaser. She knows better now).

Halfway through the movie John detached himself from Nadia’s face long enough to decide he was hungry, and asked Alfred for his pretzel bites back. By this point, Alfred had devoured the entire dish. John shrugged it off, but I could tell that he was really annoyed that Alfred would presume to eat his food. My thought: if you don’t want someone to eat all your food, don’t offer all your food. Offer a few bites. Alfred clearly felt terrible about it for the rest of the movie. We both offered to reimburse him, but he refused, getting even more annoyed about it.

When the movie finally ended, it was a relief to part ways with them. I had not really dated much at that point – I wouldn’t know how to conduct myself on my own date, much less one that I accidentally hijacked!

I called her the next day and asked that next time she is on a date and I run into her, to please not invite me along. The whole episode remains a joke to this day – “we’re such close friends, we go on each other’s dates!”

Nadia got a few texts from John after that, but they never went out again – she just had not felt any chemistry. Several months later, he texted her to wish her a happy birthday – three days later she received a call from his number. When she answered, there was a woman on the other end asking how she knew John. Turns out it was his girlfriend of three years, acting on her suspicions that John was cheating on her! Nadia explained that they had, in fact, gone on a date several months before, but that he had neglected to inform her that he had a girlfriend. Then they had a very nice conversation about how men are pigs. Nadia never heard from either of them again.

When she told me that story, my only response was “Where do you FIND these guys?!?”

Comments (31)
jamieAugust 30th, 2012 at 8:46 am

boooooorrrrrrinnnnnnggggggg…..not a bad date just awkward.

JenAugust 30th, 2012 at 9:23 am

I hate to be a troll, but the posts have been kind of downhill lately.

joAugust 30th, 2012 at 9:30 am

Completely boring. I don’t think it was a bad date. How did this get into MVWD?

EllereAugust 30th, 2012 at 9:33 am

Not boring, some good points, could have been said in 2/3 as many words to better effect. 2.5 stars.

LizAugust 30th, 2012 at 10:05 am

Who cares if it’s boring? At least it most likely happened. All the “bad date” stories on A Bad Case of the Dates are completely made up.

Currer BellAugust 30th, 2012 at 10:37 am

He wasn’t just awkward, he was also irritable, presumptuous, and a cheater. I’d say that was bad.

reviewAugust 30th, 2012 at 10:48 am

I am supremely disappoint that the OP’s friend’s date’s girlfriend keeps getting walked all over. She sticks with a guy for three years, and John still cheats on her. She’ll never get married. OP doesn’t even have the decency to name her, the only sympathetic character in this story, that I’d want to see in the sequel. She’s the only one in this story who can become Batman. The others are just henchmen.

OhDeerAugust 30th, 2012 at 10:51 am

I really don’t understand how you could keep looking back and laughing at this memory. It is such a non-memory. There is nothing eventful. So much writing you’d think it was going to get an exciting twist. But no.

JayAugust 30th, 2012 at 11:18 am

Imagine, going to a movie theater where you have to sit next to a stranger! Not sure how getting there earlier would’ve helped you.

And really, for the guy to eat the other guy’s cheesy bites, after that guy gave them to him? Wow.

But anyway.. what was the point of this story? I do believe it actually happened, but only because it’s so mundane. Fiction is stranger than truth.

OPAugust 30th, 2012 at 11:20 am

OP here.

I’ve lurked here a while, and I too have noticed the dwindling of quality in the stories. I tried to fix it by submitting an experience I had that, while not as exciting as some, still qualifies as the worst “date” I’ve experienced. I’ve been pretty lucky as far as my own dating experiences go. I’m sorry if you guys were bored – I tried to convey how funny the whole thing was in retrospect. I mean, I accidentally wound up on my best friend’s date – how ridiculously awkward is that situation? I’m chuckling remembering it now.

I didn’t give John’s girlfriend a name because, if I was ever given one, I don’t remember it. This all happened a while ago, and I didn’t hear about the aftermath until several months later because Nadia forgot to tell me about it. When she did I was like YOU NEED TO FIND A NEW PLACE TO MEET MEN.

Maybe we should adjust our attitudes about this site. The admins can only post what they’re given, you know? Maybe more of us should be submitting our own bad date stories, or spreading the word, rather than griping when we’re not entertained by every single story that is published. That way there would be a wider pool to choose from.

TraceyAugust 30th, 2012 at 11:57 am

Here’s how I read it from the POV of the OP’s friend:

“I was out at the movies with a guy I’d just met. I’m kind of shy, so when I saw my best friend out with a guy in the same theatre, I thought it would be cool (and take away some of my nerves) if I invited her to join us. Imagine my surprise when she tried to intimidate the guy! He wasn’t having it, and she sulked. Then her friend mooched my date’s pretzels. Well, once the movie started, my date leaned in for a kiss. I thought it was sweet, but he was uncomfortable because my friend kept giving him the stink eye, so he pulled away and asked for the rest of his pretzels. My friend’s date ate them all. By this time, things were awkward, so we watched the rest of the movie in silence. When it was over, we went home. The experience didn’t go well. I never heard from my date again…he chalked it up to a ‘lack of chemistry,’ but I think my friend and her date scared him off and gave him a bad impression of me. Fortunately, I’m in a much better place and speak up for myself…and I don’t invite my friend to join me when I see her in theatres any more.”

He may not have been the best person for her, but that was for her to find out on her own. Instead, you and your friend were imposing, intimidating and rude. Then you made her feel small with the “Where do you FIND these guys?” remark. OP, I do hope you treat your friend better now.

RavenAugust 30th, 2012 at 12:20 pm

Sitting next to people making out is gross and awkward.

The Dark Knight was an awesome movie.

This is all.

Drinky the Drunk GirlAugust 30th, 2012 at 12:43 pm

That is some awesome over analyzing.

66SickAugust 30th, 2012 at 1:20 pm

Good lord, Tracey, you must be off your rocker! What a bizarre extrapolation of the story, really. Do you and your friends really never snark each other? Or are you projecting?

You usually have such well-reasoned things to say, too.

TraceyAugust 30th, 2012 at 2:02 pm

@66Sick: OP rubbed me the wrong way with one simple statement – “These days she is fine, but at the time I was extremely protective of her, and suspicious of people I didn’t know….” Maybe she was really being a good friend, but the way I read it (along with that “Where do you FIND these guys” line), I just got a mean girl/frenemy vibe, especially since she defined the friend as being a “people pleaser” and herself as “very outspoken.” One person’s “very outspoken” is another person’s “intimidating bully.” That’s how I saw it. I could be wrong though. Wouldn’t be the first time.

Thanks for liking what I usually have to say, but in this case, looks like we’ll have to agree to disagree. Be well….

DaniAugust 30th, 2012 at 6:02 pm

I always tease my best friend’s dates and friends by being sarcastic, “intimidating,” mean, whatever. If they can’t handle my sense of humor, they can’t handle her sense of humor or half of our other friends’ either. Some people are people pleasers. It’s not a mean thing to say. It’s actually the kindest way of saying they are easily manipulated or pushed around. You are what you are.

JeffAugust 30th, 2012 at 7:17 pm

I somewhat agree with Tracey. The OP’s whole attitude toward her friend’s dating life is kind of creepy. On the one hand it could be construed as condescending “Oh, you clearly can’t handle your dating life without the benefit of my advice/permission.” On the other hand, there’s sort of a hint of jealousy too, that any guy the friend dates is potentially threatening her place as the bestest BFF of ever and ever. The OP writes “These days she is fine”, but it’s more likely that it’s the OP who finally got over her own insecurity and let her friend live her life.

smhAugust 30th, 2012 at 8:28 pm

i just don’t get when people go on a date and invite other friends along. a date is supposed to be between 2 people, not more. unless they all know each other and i mean all. most of the dates i had invited their friends whom I didn’t know. I guess they think the more the merrier? Bzzz. Wrong! Just no.

JillianAugust 30th, 2012 at 8:44 pm

Or maybe the OP just wants to protect someone she cares about. If someone you’re close to is constantly upset and hurt because multiple people are using her as a doormat, it’s natural to want to help her out. You guys are reading way too much into what the OP said.

PuzzledAugust 30th, 2012 at 9:00 pm

I’m sorry, I’m just too distracted by the fact that you went to the movies with a guy named Alfred, only to find a dark, shadowy figure there. Are you sure you weren’t in the movie?

CatAugust 30th, 2012 at 9:04 pm

I agree with Tracy the OP sounds like a bully…

zomboidAugust 31st, 2012 at 4:16 am

@puzzled, haha!

@OP – well, i enjoyed the story, i thought it was very well written even if no-one whipped it out or crashed their truck into a haunted house or whatever

JayAugust 31st, 2012 at 6:17 am

OP, how did you “accidentally” end up on your best friend’s date? You saw her in the theater, clearly on a date with someone, and you went and sat next to them.. on purpose.

NattieAugust 31st, 2012 at 6:20 am

It’s sweet to be protective of your friends, and lots of people have a sarcastic, teasing relationship with their closest friends. That said, if someone is a pushover and has constant dating problems, it’s possible that their self-esteem isn’t so great – “where do you FIND these guys?” may not help.

PTOAugust 31st, 2012 at 6:48 am

What Tracey and Jeff said. Mean Girl Frenemy = OP. Sounds a bit jealous. Nadia had more dating action than OP.

“Nadia was always going on and on about her work friends.” “seems like my constant line is “where do you FIND these guys?”

BobAugust 31st, 2012 at 6:54 am

Jay – she sat with them on purpose because her friend texted and invited her to sit with them. And no it wasn’t “clear” she was on a date – hence the description that the figure was shadowy at first (pretty much the opposite of clear) and when she saw it was a dude she thought it was a work friend.

Dr. CheeseAugust 31st, 2012 at 9:59 am

Nice foreshadowing, but damn that was a lot to read for such little entertainment.

KCLeaAugust 31st, 2012 at 12:45 pm

The OP was rude. If I was on a date and a friend just randomly shows up and says, “Who are you? I don’t know you,” I wouldn’t want to have much more to do with the date. The polite way to ask that would be to introduce yourself and then ask their name, jeez. That said, the date was bad but mainly because of the OP and phone call later on.

PhenSeptember 2nd, 2012 at 1:53 am

Tl;dr gegged in on friends date, ate dates pretzels, sulked, the dark night is awesome. The end.

JasonSeptember 2nd, 2012 at 5:59 am

@Liz – I sent a story into bad case of the dates there that was posted.

?September 4th, 2012 at 12:40 am

I liked the story. Definitely not anti-OP here.

Leave a comment
Your comment